Episode #4 | Rating 5 Pipes | Mr. Brog, Cracks & A Revamped System

In this video, we go through 5 estate pipes from a recent batch, grading each one using an updated numbering system. The new system includes the video number, condition (0–9), personal favorite score (0–9), a community rating, pipe number within the video, and batch letter — making every pipe's ID fully unique. Pipes covered: Old Briar (unmarked) — rusticated, tall bowl, decent condition Mr. Brog #40 — appears unsmoked, unknown wood, some glue residue Mr. Brog #41 — smoked, dark cold-brown color, loose mouthpiece Mr. Brog #47 — large billiard shape, cracked bowl interior Mr. Brog #25/35 — well-smoked, cracked shank, chew marks A few of these pipes from the Polish batch are not briar — possibly cherry wood or another unknown species. If you can help identify the wood type or pipe shapes, drop a comment below! Also in this video: a quick explanation of the updated pipe grading/ID system, and why we're switching from 10 pipes per video to 5. 👍 Like, subscribe, and comment — do you prefe